When facing a lawsuit, a defendant has two primary response options: filing a motion to dismiss or filing an answer to the complaint. Choosing the right strategy is crucial because it impacts the course of litigation, potential legal costs, and the defendant’s ability to challenge the lawsuit effectively.

This article explores the differences between a motion to dismiss and an answer, the strategic advantages of each, and how to determine which to file first.

Motion to Dismiss vs. Answer: Which Should You File First?

Introduction

When facing a lawsuit, a defendant has two primary response options: filing a motion to dismiss or filing an answer to the complaint. Choosing the right strategy is crucial because it impacts the course of litigation, potential legal costs, and the defendant’s ability to challenge the lawsuit effectively.

This article explores the differences between a motion to dismiss and an answer, the strategic advantages of each, and how to determine which to file first.

What Is a Motion to Dismiss?

A motion to dismiss is a legal request asking the court to dismiss the lawsuit before proceeding further. It argues that, even if the plaintiff’s allegations are true, there is a fundamental legal reason why the case should not move forward.

Common Grounds for Filing a Motion to Dismiss

• Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction – The court does not have the authority to hear the case.

• Lack of Personal Jurisdiction – The court has no legal power over the defendant.

• Improper Venue – The case was filed in the wrong court location.

• Failure to State a Claim – The complaint does not allege facts that, if true, would establish a legal claim.

• Statute of Limitations – The plaintiff filed the lawsuit after the legal deadline expired.

• Insufficient Service of Process – The defendant was not properly notified of the lawsuit.

If the motion to dismiss is granted, the case is either dismissed permanently (with prejudice) or temporarily (without prejudice, allowing the plaintiff to refile with corrections).

What Is an Answer?

An answer is the defendant’s formal written response to the plaintiff’s complaint. Instead of trying to dismiss the case, it admits, denies, or asserts defenses against the plaintiff’s allegations.

Key Elements of an Answer

• Admissions or Denials – The defendant either agrees or disputes each allegation.

• Affirmative Defenses – Legal reasons why the plaintiff’s claim should fail (e.g., self-defense, contributory negligence).

• Counterclaims or Crossclaims – The defendant may assert claims against the plaintiff or third parties.

Once an answer is filed, the case proceeds to discovery, where both parties exchange evidence.

Key Differences Between a Motion to Dismiss and an Answer

FeatureMotion to DismissAnswerPurposeChallenges legal sufficiency of the complaintResponds to allegations and asserts defensesTimingFiled before answering the complaintFiled after or in place of a motion to dismissLegal ArgumentsProcedural and jurisdictional challengesFactual defenses and counterclaimsPossible OutcomesCase may be dismissed entirely or amendedCase proceeds to discovery and trialStrategic BenefitAvoids unnecessary litigation if successfulPreserves defenses and counters plaintiff’s claims

Which Should You File First?

When to File a Motion to Dismiss First

Filing a motion to dismiss is the best strategy when:

• The court lacks jurisdiction, preventing the case from proceeding at all.

• The lawsuit is procedurally defective, such as improper service or lack of standing.

• The claim is legally insufficient, meaning that even if all facts are true, there’s no valid claim.

• The case is time-barred due to the statute of limitations.

• The venue is incorrect, and the defendant wants to avoid litigating in an inconvenient court.

When to File an Answer First

Filing an answer is the best option when:

• The complaint is legally sufficient, meaning there are no clear grounds for dismissal.

• The defendant wants to preserve defenses and assert counterclaims.

• A motion to dismiss would likely be denied, leading to unnecessary delays.

• The goal is to move forward to discovery and trial preparation.

Can You File Both?

Yes! Some legal rules allow defendants to file a motion to dismiss and, if denied, file an answer afterward. However, filing an answer first may waive certain defenses that could have been raised in a motion to dismiss.

How Legal Husk Can Help

At Legal Husk, we specialize in drafting strategic motions to dismiss and answers that align with court rules and procedural strategy. Our services ensure that: ✅ Your response is legally sound and persuasive. ✅ You preserve all possible defenses. ✅ You follow strict filing deadlines to avoid procedural missteps.

Final Thoughts

Filing a motion to dismiss or an answer is a critical decision that requires legal insight and strategy. Understanding the best approach can help defendants protect their rights and avoid unnecessary litigation.

📩 Need expert assistance with your legal documents? Contact Legal Husk today!